Ashley Reeves: Strangled and Left for Dead for 30 Hours
January 9, 2026
Listen on: Spotify | Apple Podcasts
In April 2006, the small town of Millstadt, Illinois, was shaken when 17-year-old Ashley Reeves vanished without a trace. What began as a missing person case quickly unraveled a story of secrets, manipulation, and a brutal attack that left a young woman fighting for her life in the cold woods. This is the story of Ashley Reeves and her incredible will to survive.
A Secret Relationship
Ashley Reeves was a responsible and well-liked teenager. She had a serious boyfriend and was a typical high school student who enjoyed playing basketball and hanging out with friends. In early 2006, she struck up a friendship with 26-year-old Samson Shelton, a popular teacher and coach from a neighboring high school.
The two would meet at a local park to play basketball, often alone. While Ashley saw it as a close friendship, her mother suspected a schoolgirl crush. The reality was much more complicated. The friendship escalated to text messages and phone calls, a secret relationship that crossed a dangerous line.
The Disappearance
On April 27, 2006, Ashley told her mother she had a job interview and borrowed the family car. Instead, she went to meet Samson Shelton at the park. She was supposed to be home by 10:00 PM to babysit her younger sister, but she never returned.
When Ashley missed her curfew and wasn't answering her phone, her mother, Michelle, grew frantic. A call to Ashley's best friend confirmed her fears—no one had heard from her. It was then that Michelle and Ashley's sister, Casey, discovered a frequently called number on the phone bill. That number belonged to Samson Shelton.
The Investigation & Confession
When police located Ashley's abandoned car at the park, their investigation immediately focused on Samson Shelton. During an 11-hour interrogation, Samson's story began to crumble. He initially denied any involvement but eventually admitted to a secret sexual relationship with the 17-year-old.
He claimed he had tried to end the relationship that day, which led to an argument. According to Samson, Ashley became hysterical, and in a fit of rage, he pulled the car over, dragged her out, and put her in a chokehold. He told detectives he heard a "pop" and her body went limp.
In a panic, thinking she was dead, he dragged her into the woods, strangled her with his own belt to stage the scene, and left her for dead.
A Miraculous Discovery
After his confession, Samson Shelton led police to the heavily wooded area where he had left Ashley. It was 2:00 AM, nearly 48 hours after the attack. As officers searched the pitch-black woods, they made a shocking discovery: Ashley Reeves was alive.
She was found lying on her back, covered in insect bites, and exposed to the elements for two days. She was awake but unresponsive, her neck appearing broken. The journey to get her to a hospital was a race against time, with paramedics fearing she wouldn't survive.
The Road to Recovery
Ashley had suffered a severe brain injury, and doctors gave her a statistically low chance of survival. She spent months in the hospital, slowly relearning how to walk, talk, and perform basic functions. Her memory of the attack and the days surrounding it was completely gone.
Despite the horrific trauma, Ashley's determination shone through. She not only survived but has gone on to build a life for herself. Today, Ashley Reeves is a mother of two and continues to inspire others with her story of resilience.
Justice for Ashley
Samson Shelton pleaded guilty to attempted first-degree murder and was sentenced to 20 years in prison. While out on bail awaiting trial, he attempted to take his own life.
The community was divided, with some defending the "popular teacher" while Ashley and her family faced victim-blaming. But in the end, the evidence was undeniable, and a monster was put behind bars.
