[FLORIDA FILES] OnlyFans Model Courtney Clenney: Self-Defense or Cold-Blooded Murder?

listen on spotify
Listen on Apple Podcast

The Fatal Night in a Miami High-Rise

On April 3, 2022, a frantic 911 call from a luxury Miami apartment set off a chain of events that would capture national attention. OnlyFans model Courtney Clenney, known online as Courtney Tailor, claimed her boyfriend, Christian Obumseli, had been stabbed. She pleaded for help, but by the time first responders arrived, it was too late. Christian, just 27 years old, died from a single, deep stab wound to the chest. Clenney asserted she acted in self-defense, throwing a knife from across the room after Christian allegedly attacked her. But the evidence told a different story, one of a prolonged and bloody struggle that spanned multiple rooms, leaving investigators to question if this was a justifiable act or a cold-blooded killing.

A Volatile Relationship Exposed

As investigators dug into the couple's two-year relationship, a disturbing pattern of volatility and violence emerged. Friends and neighbors reported a history of explosive arguments, and building management was on the verge of evicting the couple from their $10,000-a-month condo due to constant disturbances. The prosecution's evidence includes shocking surveillance footage from an elevator, captured just weeks before the stabbing, showing Clenney repeatedly attacking Christian. Even more chilling are the secret recordings Christian began making, capturing Clenney's verbal abuse, racial slurs, and demands to physically harm him. In one haunting text message sent shortly before his death, Christian asked, "Is love going to kill me?"

Self-Defense or Murder? The Evidence in Question

The central question of the case remains: was this self-defense? The medical examiner's report directly contradicts Courtney's claim of throwing the knife, stating the fatal wound required a forceful, downward thrust inconsistent with a thrown weapon. Furthermore, police found no injuries on Clenney to support her story of being choked and thrown to the ground, and it was confirmed that Christian was unarmed. The legal battle has become a complex web of its own, with accusations of prosecutorial misconduct, including improperly accessed attorney-client privileged communications and the withholding of a potential witness who claims to have seen Christian assault Courtney. The defense also alleges that crucial crime scene photos taken by a witness were ordered to be deleted by police.

The Case Today

Courtney Clenney was arrested in Hawaii in August 2022 and charged with second-degree murder. She is currently being held without bond in a Miami correctional center, deemed a flight risk by the court. Her legal team continues to fight for the suppression of key evidence, including Christian's secret recordings, while the prosecution builds its case around a clear pattern of domestic abuse where Christian was the victim. With a trial date pushed to at least 2026, the world watches and waits to see how this tragic story of love, violence, and social media fame will end.

Have a case you want us to cover? Send your suggestions to momsandmysteries@gmail.com.

Don't forget to leave us a review and subscribe on YouTube!

🎧 **Prefer to listen on your favorite platform?** - Listen on Spotify - Listen on Apple Podcasts - All Links: https://linktr.ee/Momsandmysteries





Next
Next

10 High-Profile True Crime Trials to Watch in 2026