Search ALL Episodes Here…
Browse Episodes by Category:
The Vanishing of Cindy Song
Happy almost November 1st (or just Happy Halloween if you are not weird like Melissa and aren’t terrified of Halloween). This week Mandy forced Melissa to talk about a Halloween case, but in a true portrayal of friendship, she did not choose anything too scary or ghost related. This week the ladies are discussing the unsolved case of Cindy Song who went missing after attending a Halloween party. They also take a deep (deep deep deep) dive into one of the main suspects of her disappearance, Hugo Selenski. Grab a notebook and a diet coke because this one is going to take some brain power.
The Suitcase Murder: The Jasmine Fiore Story
Jasmine Fiore was a small town girl with dreams of living a big city life. After meeting Ryan Jenkins she thought she had found her prince, but she could not have been more wrong. Listen in as we discuss the rise and fall of reality star Ryan Jenkins and the heartbreaking murder of his new bride, Jasmine Fiore. This week Melissa talks Brett Michaels and terrible reality shows, and Mandy may or may not have created the most earth shattering invention in the modern age (patent pending).
A Crime of Passion: The Clara Harris Story
Clara Harris was a Mom, Wife, Dentist, and the subject of the most terrible Lifetime Movie of all time. Today the ladies talk the death of David Harris at the hands of his wife, Clara. Was it a cold-blooded murder, a crime of passion, or a terrible accident? Also, learn why Mandy would be a terrible mid-wife, what would cause Melissa to go off of a cliff, and why comparison lists are always a terrible, horrible, no good idea.
The Clear Lake Murders: A Friendship to Die For
*This week’s episode was recorded prior to the massacre in Las Vegas. In this episode we discuss “The Clear Lake Murders”, and we understand if it’s not something you are ready to hear about after the events of the week.*
Another day, another crime. Join us as we lay out the facts on the senseless tragedy of the Clear Lake Murders. Melissa and Mandy converse about how terrible high school superlatives are. Was Melissa an all-star high school athlete? Is Mandy a closet Bieber fan? Will the ladies ruin your favorite movie from the 80’s? (Hint: Most likely)
The Murder of Fire Lt. William Walker: A Cleveland Murder for Hire Plot
Cleveland Fire Lt. William Walker was killed in a murder for hire plot after a late night food run. Four people joined the conspiracy, and texts helped expose it.
The Murder of Kelley Clayton: A Husband's Ultimate Betrayal
In September 2015, 35-year-old Kelley Clayton was brutally beaten to death in her Caton, New York home. While her husband, former hockey pro Thomas Clayton, claimed to have a solid poker-night alibi, their seven-year-old daughter's description of the masked killer pointed directly to a sinister murder-for-hire plot. This week we cover the tragic murder of Kelley Clayton and the ultimate betrayal of a husband's greed.
Frederic Bourdin: Kidnapped Victim or International Fraudster?
This week, the ears have it! Join Melissa with her very special guest, her sister Megan, as they break down the strange but true story of Frederic Bourdin. Find out whether or not you can smoke in Spain, how to get a quick group home tattoo, and stick around for THE craziest #ImInvincibleWhen we’ve had to date. #RobbableFace
The Murder of Sherri Rasmussen: A Killer in Uniform
In February 1986, 29-year-old nursing director Sherri Rasmussen was found brutally murdered in her Van Nuys condo. Police insisted it was a botched burglary, ignoring her family's warnings about a stalking ex-girlfriend. Twenty-three years later, DNA from a bite mark revealed the killer was actually Stephanie Lazarus, an active-duty LAPD detective. This week we cover the tragic murder of Sherri Rasmussen and the shocking betrayal of the badge.
The Mysterious Death of Rebecca Zahau
This week we are diving deep into the mysterious death of Rebecca Zahau. Was it murder? Was it suicide? Are Tug Boat Captains a real thing? We will discuss all of this and more on this week’s episode of Moms and Murder. You will learn why you should never let Melissa call 911 for you and find out about the only kind of knot Mandy can tie.
Anthony Curcio: The Craigslist Bank Robber
Join us this week as we discuss our favorite bank heist, and story of Anthony Curcio. This robbery is one of the most elaborate and creative that you’ll ever hear and Anthony may have gotten away with it if it wasn’t for the keen eye of an unlikely stranger.
Also, Melissa explains why she wishes she was in solitaire confinement, Mandy reads a hilarious snippet from Anthony’s children’s book, and we might actually save your life with this week’s #iminvinciblewhen.
Episode"There's Something Wrong with Aunt Diane": The Diane Schuler Story
This week we discuss the 2009 Taconic State Parkway crash of Diane Schuler and the seven victims of this terrible wreck : Emma Hance (8), Alyson Hance (7), Kate Hance (5), Erin Schuler (2), Michael Bastardi (81 ), Daniel Longo (74), and Guy Bastardi (49). Melissa and Mandy discuss the timeline of this heartbreaking story, a GoFundMe we can all get behind, and the most enraging lawsuit in the history of ever.
Erin Caffey: The Girl Who Murdered Her Family for "Love"
As the late, great, Aaliyah once said “Age ain’t nothing but a number”… that is, unless you’re a 20 year old high school senior dating your 16 year old classmate who has decided to have her entire family killed and needs your help! Then the number to focus on is not how many years between birthdays, but how many birthdays you’ll spend behind bars.
[Serial Killer] Todd Kohlhepp: The Amazon Reviews of a Serial Killer
Todd Kohlhepp: America’s Least Favorite Amazon Reviewer.
This week we move out of Florida into the land of South Carolina…well, sort of. We are discussing the bewildering case of Todd Kohlhepp, who was either a “good boy” or American serial killer depending on whether you ask his mother or literally any other member of the human race. #toddyboy
BONUS - Mini Episode: Dalia Dippolito
First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes… a hired hit man?! Join us in our first Bonus-Mini Episode as we do a quick breakdown on the love affair of Mike and Dalia Dippolito and her lover/police informant. This case just came to a resolution, so you guys are the first to know!
[Florida Files] Casey Anthony: The Trial and the Theories (Part 2)
It’s #truecrimetuesday, and that means it’s part 2 of the Casey Anthony saga, now with 50% less of Melissa and Mandy saying “By all accounts”, but even more Google shout-outs! Find out what happens in court, and where Casey is now (Hint- she may be looking at this right now!) and why Melissa hearts Leonard Padilla. Plus, we have a new segment called #iminvinciblewhen and we need your ideas! Please remember to subscribe and rate us 5 stars, because 4 stars would be a crime.
[Florida Files] Casey Anthony: A Mom's Betrayal (Part 1)
It’s our inaugural podcast! Join us as we breakdown the Curious Case of Casey Anthony on this week’s Moms and Murder podcast. Learn about the key players, why it’s important to only get tattoos in the languages you speak, and why we are both married…hint- we hate shoveling!
