Search ALL Episodes Here…

NEW EPISODES EVERY TUESDAY & THURSDAY!

Listen on Spotify
Listen on Apple Podcast

Have an idea for an episode, or a story you’d like us to cover? Write us.

Browse Episodes by Category:

[Florida Files]
[Murder]
[Unsolved]
[Serial Killer]
[Missing]
[Mystery]
[Crossover]
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Murder of Martha Puebla

This week The Moms are examining the case of a young woman who was murdered after accusing a gang member of murdering her friend. Or did she? There’s a lot to unload in this story this week and that even includes baseball, forged signatures, and one of Melissa’s favorite television stars.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Murder of Tanya Tandoc

The Moms are back! After a week off for family visitors and selling houses we are back and gigglier than ever. This week the format is a little different as we had a shorter case. We debut a new segment in the beginning that quickly goes off the rails and even add in a piece of Reddit “information” at the end (against Melissa’s better judgement).

This week’s case covers the murder of an amazing and eclectic woman in Kansas, and the coward who took advantage of her generosity and ultimately took her life.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Murders of Carla Cannon and Mona King

This week we are discussing a case of two sisters, murdered in their own home. Lt. Joe “nickname TBA” Kenda was on the case, and we talk about everyone and everything including Michael Jackson, Frank Sinatra, and the Real Housewives. We also read a Yelp review that is so powerful, it brings down a long-time Colorado establishment (okay, maybe not). Our #LastThingBeforeWeGo may fill you with rage. Sorry, not sorry.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Ashley Reeves Story: A Chilling Case of Attempted Murder and Miraculous Survival

A basketball coach, a teenager and country line dancing, three things that shouldn’t go together but this week, they do. Join us as we will lay out the story of a gruesome crime, with a twist of sorts. We’ll end it with a #LastThingBeforeWeGo for the lazy bums in us all.

Check out this week’s sponsor, MyBargainBuddy.com! If you love bargains as much as we do, you will be head over heels for My Bargain Buddy!

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Murder of Kathleen Peterson With Special Guest Host, Ali Sweeney

This week we have a super special Sweeney-sode! Join us as we discuss the favorite case of our new best friend (our words, not hers), Ali Sweeney! You guys know Ali from her work on Days of Our Lives, or as the former host of the Biggest Loser, or maybe you know her from her work as an author, director and quite possibly for being the coolest person on the internet. Ali is a HUGE true crime fan (and Mom of two!) and we were lucky enough to have her on as a third host! This week we discuss a case that has all the ingredients to make a fascinating story. Maybe it was murder, maybe multiple murders, there was definitely affairs, and possibly homicidal owls? Stay to the end for a special “Last Thing Before We Go” starring Ali!

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Brentwood Murders with Special Guest Derrick Levasseur

Join us this week for our super-sized episode on the infamous Brentwood murders. We discuss the theories, the investigation and the suspects we never heard about. We also break down the ID series “Is OJ Innocent, The Missing Evidence” and had a chance to speak with one of the stars of the show, Derrick Levasseur, who was also an undercover officer and winner of Big Brother Season 16. We discuss his upcoming projects as well as his new book “The Undercover Edge”.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Dexter Copycat Killer: The Murder of Johnny Altinger

Emails and ski masks and Dexter, oh my! This week the ladies discuss The Dexter Morgan Copycat Killer. We’ll chat about the most important things like why Chili’s is the ultimate date location and how to know if you are Jay-Z (hint: you aren’t). And of course we try our new hashtag game out, #LastThingBeforeWeGo. Be prepared to have opinions, we do.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Murder of Kari Baker

This week we talk about the death of a prominent Pastor’s wife, Kari Baker. Was it suicide or was it murder? Join us as we break down the details of this shocking story that’s sure to fire you up.

Make sure you stay for the end of the episode for a new hashtag, #LastThingBeforeWeGo

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Disappearance of Zebb Quinn

This week we are discussing the disappearance of Zebb Quinn. In the past year there have been several developments in this case, and we are breaking them down for you. Plus we ask the hard hitting questions, like what does Superman do without phone booths to change into? Did people have cordless phones back in 2000? And will Mandy get Melissa’s Conan O’Brien reference (spoiler alert: no)?

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Interview with #IMomSoHard

This week there’s a little bit of murder, and a whole lot of Moms. Join us as we discuss parenting, true crime obsessions and hemorrhoids in our episode with Jen Smedley and Kristin Hensley of the insanely popular #IMomSoHard videos. Nothing is off limits as we talk about Adnan Syed, the loathsome nature of Christmas cards, Robert Durst’s burping issues (or maybe that’s just Melissa) and even Nebraska’s infamous serial killers. We also play a special game of “Never Have I Ever-The Parenting Version” to win a prize from one of our listeners.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Gonzales Family Murders

Welcome back! This week we are headed to the land down under to discuss the murders of the Gonzales family in Australia. What would drive a seemingly normal young adult to kill his entire family? Hint: greed, and being an overall terrible human.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Tragedy in Arkansas

We’re back! After a one week hiatus (like the cool kids say), we are back on the saddle and starting 2018 with a riveting case. This week we are discussing the abduction and murder of a top real estate agent in Arkansas. We discuss the perpetrator’s complicated history, but more importantly we talk about the loving wife, mother, grandmother and friend who was taken far too soon.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Sameena Imam

Merry everything, everyone! This week the show’s format is a little different. The first half of the show is spent discussing the tragic and unusual murder of Sameena Imam. Sameena was a beautiful English woman who fell in love with a man who only really loved himself.

The second half of this episode (beginning at 25:15) is a discussion all about holiday traditions and an end of the year wrap up. This year was a wonderful year for us and we are so thankful for each and every one of you!

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Jenelle Potter

Happy Holidays, friends! Get ready for a shocker of a show this week. Join Melissa and Mandy as they discuss the murder of Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne, two parents, killed over a social media un-friending. This story has so many twists and turns, and you may want to rip out a page from your Oprah dream journal to keep track of all the players.

Also find out the one trash show Mandy watches and who Melissa will hide on Facebook (no one is safe). Learn the rules of being in the CIA and hear Mandy use more slang than is appropriate for women their age.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Justin Michael

This week the ladies are Manksless and back to your regularly scheduled programming. Join the ladies as they discuss the devastating murder of Justin Michael. Justin was a friend, son and fiancé. Who would want to kill Justin just feet away from him Mom and soon to be bride? Melissa and Mandy discuss the twists and turns of this real life whodunnit mystery. Also, find out which Mom has voluntarily jumped out of a plane and why they are swooning over the coolest guy to own a metal detector.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Interview With Dateline's Josh Mankiewicz

What do you get when you mix Dateline’s Josh “The Manks” Mankiewicz and the ladies of Moms and Murder together? The best show ever! Join us this week as we talk behind the scenes of Dateline, why Manks believes the world is fascinated with true crime, the history behind the infamous Mankiewicz GIF and who would be the most likely suspect in Melissa’s ultimate demise. Mandy and Josh also play a special game of “Dateline Episode or Hardy Boys Mystery” for a very lucky listener…or unlucky listener depending on who was playing.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

The Bling Ring

20 Episodes in and we decided to skip the homicide and settle in for a good old fashion tale of Hollywood’s Bling Ring. The ladies discuss one of the greatest clips in all of Reality Show history (even Mandy agrees!) and Melissa plays a game of “things I’d grab in a fire” and Mandy writes a terrifying children’s story called “Paris Hilton and the Three Little Bears”. We have a huge announcement regarding next week’s show and it includes how you can win free merch from our merch store AND maybe a special guest.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Vampire Cult Killers

When you think of Moms and Murder the first thing you think is “Vampire Cult Killers”, right? Well, this week you will. Join the Moms as they discuss the NOT TOTALLY FLORIDA, Vampire Cult, why it matters who you hang out with, and more of the old crowd mentality. Make sure you listen to this one quickly, as some of the key players could be out of prison soon and we don’t need that in our lives.

Read More
Rachel Bennett Rachel Bennett

Darlene Gentry

Today we’re discussing the unjustifiable death of devoted husband and father, Keith Gentry, and we will examine how his wife, Darlene found herself at the center of the investigation. Mandy goes on a weird rant about organ donation and offers up wisdom on where not to hide evidence. Melissa struggles with “manmade” vs. “naturally occurring” and introduces us to a key player who may just be the male version of herself. In the end, we both agree that you should always lawyer-up BEFORE being formally interrogated by police, and also that we need a thesaurus. And we have a big announcement. Huge. Giant. GINORMOUS!

Read More