Search ALL Episodes Here…
Browse Episodes by Category:
Summer Shenanigans: Crimes of the Season
This week, we're taking a break from heavy true crime to share quirky summer crimes from quintessential vacation spots—beaches, ice cream shops, campgrounds, and lakes. From a filmmaker who exposed a theft ring targeting surfers in Newport Beach to a Michigan man stealing from campground payment boxes, these stories are lighthearted and bizarre. We'll also cover boat thefts in Germany and ice cream heists that required "pint locks." If you're looking for fun, quirky true crime, this episode is perfect. Crime doesn't take a summer vacation—it just gets more creative!
The Vanishing of Melissa Caddick: A Stylish Sydney Life and a Multi-Million Dollar Ponzi Scheme
She was wealthy, stylish, and appeared to be living the dream life in Sydney, Australia. Then, without a trace, Melissa Caddick vanished. The mystery of her disappearance was only the beginning of a bizarre and captivating scandal that would unravel in the wake of her going missing. This episode dives into the life she projected, the multi-million dollar Ponzi scheme she was allegedly running, and the shocking discovery of a severed, decaying foot that washed up on a beach—which was later identified as belonging to Melissa. Join us as we explore the facts and fun facts of Australia, including the true fate of the con artist who disappeared into thin air.
The Notorious B.I.G.: An Unsolved Murder
Before he was the Notorious B.I.G., Christopher Wallace was a kid from Brooklyn with big dreams. His rise to rap superstardom was meteoric, but it was cut short on March 9, 1997, when he was shot and killed in a drive-by shooting in Los Angeles. He was just 24 years old. Despite multiple witnesses, FBI investigations, and decades of speculation, his murder remains unsolved. Theories include gang retaliation, corrupt LAPD officers, and revenge for Tupac's death. This episode explores Biggie's life, the East Coast-West Coast rivalry, and the mystery that haunts hip-hop history.
Rust Part 1: The Tragic Death of Halyna Hutchins
On October 21, 2021, cinematographer Halyna Hutchins was killed on the set of the Western film Rust when a gun held by Alec Baldwin discharged during a rehearsal. The bullet struck Halyna in the chest, and she died from her injuries. She was 42 years old. How did a live round end up in a prop gun? Who was responsible? In Part 1, we explore the events leading up to Halyna's death, the chaotic production, the unqualified armorer, and the critical safety failures that turned a routine rehearsal into a fatal disaster.
Rust Part 2: The Search for Accountability
In Part 1, we explored the tragic death of Halyna Hutchins on the set of Rust. In Part 2, we dive into the investigations and trials. Where did the live ammunition come from? Who was responsible? Investigators uncovered cost-cutting, unqualified staff, and ignored safety protocols. Armorer Hannah Gutierrez-Reed was forced to juggle two jobs. Alec Baldwin claimed he never pulled the trigger. The assistant director admitted he didn't check the gun. This episode examines the criminal charges and the difficult question of accountability when a preventable tragedy occurs.
Jailbreak: The Hole Behind the Toilet
From the outside, a prison is supposed to be impenetrable. But throughout history, inmates have used planning, luck, and shocking ingenuity to pull off some of the most daring escapes the world has ever seen. This week, we're diving into the legendary prison breaks, from those involving elaborate disguises and sheep, to the more shocking trend of helicopter escapes. We look at how inmates managed to learn to fly, bypass high-security walls, and why the most unlikely plans sometimes turn out to be the most successful. This episode is a wild look at the human will to be free, and the unexpected ways people try to game the system.
The Campbell Murder: A Daughter's Deadly Betrayal
On June 19, 1982, James and Virginia Campbell were shot to death in their Houston home while they slept. The shocking answer to who killed them: their own daughter Cindy and her boyfriend David West. Cindy stood to inherit money and was willing to murder her parents to get it—while her young children slept down the hall. This case features one of the most incredible undercover investigations in true crime history, as a 23-year-old private investigator befriended David West for months to extract a confession. A chilling story of greed, betrayal, and family murder.
[Crossover] P. Diddy: The Case Explained with I Think Not Podcast
This week, we're joined by Ellen Marsh from I Think Not podcast for a special crossover episode all about Sean "Diddy" Combs! Ellen is our go-to expert on all things Diddy, and she breaks down the shocking allegations, the timeline, and what to expect as the trial unfolds. From his rise as a music mogul to his arrest, we're covering everything you need to know. This episode serves as a beginner's intro to the Diddy case, perfect whether you've been following every detail or you're just catching up. Don't miss this deep dive!
[Unsolved] Justice for Trish Haynes
In early 2018, 25-year-old Trish Haynes told her family she was heading to New Hampshire to clear up a court matter. Then she vanished. Four months later, a shocking discovery was made: a jawbone sealed inside a washing machine at the bottom of Grant Pond. Trish had been raised by her devoted grandparents and had dreams of modeling. She had a big heart and saw the best in everyone. Despite ample circumstantial evidence, no one has ever been held accountable for her murder. This is Trish's story, told with the help of her family.
[Update] Bianca Rudolph: The Safari Murder
In October 2016, Bianca Rudolph was found dead from a gunshot wound in a Zambian safari cabin. Her husband Larry claimed it was an accident, but investigators discovered a pattern of infidelity, a long-term affair with his office manager Lori Milliron, and nearly $5 million in life insurance payouts. This update episode covers the full story—from the suspicious death to the investigation, trial, and verdict. Larry Rudolph was convicted of murder and mail fraud. Lori was convicted as an accessory. Justice for Bianca came years later, but it finally came.
[Florida Files] Casey Anthony Revisited
This is where it all began. In 2017, our very first episode covered the Casey Anthony case. Eight years later, we're revisiting this infamous story with fresh perspective and updated information. In 2008, two-year-old Caylee Anthony disappeared from Orlando. Her mother Casey waited 31 days to report her missing. When Caylee's remains were found, Casey was charged with murder. The trial shocked the nation. Recently, Casey re-emerged on social media, rebranding herself as an advocate. This renewed episode is our definitive deep dive into one of the most controversial cases in true crime history.
Skylar Neese: Murdered by Her Best Friends
On July 6, 2012, 16-year-old Skylar Neese slipped out of her bedroom window to meet her two best friends, Sheila Eddy and Rachel Shoaf. She never came home. The girls told Skylar's parents they had dropped her off at midnight and didn't know where she went. But months later, Rachel confessed: she and Sheila had lured Skylar into the woods and murdered her. When asked why, Rachel's answer was chilling: "We didn't want to be friends with her anymore." This is the story of an unthinkable betrayal in a small West Virginia town.
[Unsolved] Jill Dando: Britain's Beloved Presenter
On April 26, 1999, beloved British television presenter Jill Dando was shot and killed on her London doorstep in broad daylight. The murder shocked the UK and sparked one of the largest investigations in British history. Barry George was convicted in 2001 but acquitted in 2008 due to lack of evidence. Despite decades of investigation and countless theories, Jill Dando's murder remains unsolved. Who killed one of Britain's most beloved TV personalities?
[Update] Marie Versos & Debbie Cisco: The Murders That Changed Ohio Law
On October 2, 2018, Cheryl Coker vanished from her Riverside, Ohio home. Her SUV was found in a Kroger parking lot with her purse and phone inside. Cheryl—a bubbly mom and grandmother—had not left voluntarily. For 18 months, her family searched desperately. In April 2020, her remains were found in a wooded area. Police believe she was murdered at home. The only person of interest is her husband, Bill Coker. Despite strong evidence, no charges have been filed. Cheryl's family is still waiting for justice.
Ruth Ellis: The Last Woman Hanged in Britain
In 1955, Ruth Ellis shot and killed her abusive lover David Blakely outside a London pub. At trial, she showed no remorse and admitted she intended to kill him. The jury took 14 minutes to convict her. On July 13, 1955, Ruth became the last woman executed in the UK. Her story is one of domestic abuse, desperation, and a legal system that failed her. Her execution sparked outrage and helped abolish capital punishment in Britain.
[Florida Files] Bone Valley: The Leo Schofield Case
In 1987, Michelle Schofield was murdered in Lakeland, Florida. Her husband Leo was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. But Leo has always maintained his innocence. The Bone Valley podcast, created by Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Gilbert King, uncovered shocking evidence never presented at trial: DNA pointing to another suspect, ignored witness testimony, and a serial killer's confession. Despite this new evidence, Leo remains in prison. This episode features an interview with Gilbert King about his investigation and Leo's ongoing fight for freedom.
[Unsolved] Ryan Shtuka: Missing in Sun Peaks, British Columbia
On February 17, 2018, 20-year-old Ryan Shtuka left a house party in Sun Peaks, British Columbia, and vanished. What should have been a short walk home became a haunting mystery. Despite extensive searches involving hundreds of volunteers and specialized teams, no trace of Ryan has been found. His family created the Shtuka Sora search organization and continues fighting for answers. Ryan's mother describes being caught between grief and hope—unable to fully grieve, but unable to give up.
Mystery Drones: The 2019 Sky Invasion (Interview with Obscure Podcast)
In late 2019 and early 2020, residents of rural Colorado, Nebraska, and Kansas reported massive swarms of mysterious drones flying over their property at night. Law enforcement saw 50 at once. Locals described large white drones surrounded by smaller ones with flashing lights. The FAA and FBI investigated but never solved the mystery. This episode features Gabe from the Obscure podcast, who investigated the phenomenon firsthand. Were they government surveillance? Private companies? Something else? The mystery remains unsolved.
[Unsolved] Brian Shaffer: The Man Who Vanished from a Bar
On April 1, 2006, 27-year-old medical student Brian Shaffer went to the Ugly Tuna Saloona bar in Columbus, Ohio with friends. Security cameras captured him entering—but he was never seen leaving. When the bar closed, Brian had vanished. Despite extensive searches and hundreds of tips, no trace of Brian has been found in nearly 20 years. How does someone disappear from a crowded bar without being captured on camera? This case remains one of Ohio's most baffling unsolved mysteries.
[Mystery] The Ghost Blimp: The L-8's Vanished Crew
On August 16, 1942, a US Navy blimp lifted off from San Francisco on routine patrol. Hours later, it crashed in Daly City—but the two crew members had vanished. The doors were open, equipment untouched, no distress call, no sign of struggle. Just an empty blimp drifting like a ghost ship. Eighty years later, the mystery remains unsolved. What happened to Lieutenant Ernest Cody and Ensign Charles Adams? This is one of the strangest unsolved mysteries in American military history.
